Dr. Doug Cardell

An Eclectic Economist Explains Evidentiary Economics

Clear Thinking in a Complicated World

“Ideology asks for acceptance—Intelligence asks for evidence.”
Why Socialism Struggles book cover
Buy Dr. Cardell's Book

Why Socialism Struggles

Recent Articles   About Dr. Cardell   See Dr. Doug on Podcasts

Featured Article:

   
   October 22, 2022

The welfare state is essentially a codependent relationship with the populace. It is a means of controlling the citizenry and maintaining a hold on power. Those who advocate for an expanded welfare state believe that segments of the population are inadequately equipped, by birth or by circumstance, to cope with the demands of day-to-day living. However, those in power, or wish to be, recognize that appealing to these advocates can be used to gain and retain control. They have found that creating codependent government programs accomplishes those ends. Codependents are also known as "enablers" because they allow the ones who depend on them to keep engaging in unhealthy behaviors. Codependency is a dysfunctional relationship dynamic where one actor assumes the role of "the giver," sacrificing their own needs and those of others for the sake of the dependent, "the taker." As a result, codependents do harm disguised as good to satisfy their own emotional needs. The symptoms include: having a hard time saying no, showing emotional reactivity, feeling compelled to take care of people, feeling a need to be liked by everyone, having a hunger for control over others, and having trouble communicating honestly. Socialists are prone to label those who disagree with them as mean and heartless but attempting to end a codependency relationship is by far the kinder position. Codependency does not help people; it is a destructive behavior that only exists to satisfy the emotional needs of the enabler. Enablers exploit others and cripple those they purport to be helping. The welfare state policy expansions that began in the sixties have done generations of harm to black families while the enablers applauded their own virtue. Unfortunately, they've succeeded in portraying their ego satisfaction as a noble effort to improve minorities' lives. They continued the ruse despite overwhelming evidence that their programs created more harm than good. They are doing the moral equivalent of providing alcohol to an alcoholic so they, the enablers, can feel like saviors for giving the alcoholic what the alcoholic wants. Anyone who has ever dealt with an alcoholic can tell you that it is difficult and painful for a caring person to watch an alcoholic suffering withdrawal and denying them the alcohol they crave. Sadly, enablers lack the courage to do the hard work of not enabling, so they choose the easy way and undermine the alcoholic's recovery by giving them what they want. The left's power elite, the architects of these policies, are particularly guilty. Their actions are not accidental and unintended; they are an inherent part of their plan to take and hold power. Just as any codependent exercises power over the dependent with the threat of 'cutting them off", these power elite do the same thing. First, they provide funds, let's say for education, then they use the threat of removing those funds to enforce policies important to their agenda. They have employed the same tactics throughout the federal agencies. They can accomplish this because they can convince Americans who want to help others that these programs are well intended and will successfully solve problems like poverty. However, the evidence says they cannot. According to the census bureau, the family poverty rate was 8.8 percent in 1973; since then, it has been as high as 12.3 percent in 1993, during the Clinton administration, and as low as 7.8 percent in 2019, during the Trump administration. The 50-year average is 10.3 percent. In 2021 the last full year of data at this time, the family poverty rate was 8.8 percent, exactly where it started fifty years ago. These enablers have misled millions of caring Americans who truly believed these enablers' schemes were helping people. Hopefully, these millions will learn the truth over time and see that, however pure their motives are, they have been manipulated into encouraging harmful policies. Furthermore, we can hope that they will come to believe that all people have worth and can succeed on their terms if the government no longer enables the behaviors that have kept them from achieving their dreams.

If you found this article stimulating, you'll probably love my book, Why Socialism Struggles. If you share my concern about creeping socialism, please share this article with other folks who might enjoy it and link to it on your social media. And please share your thoughts below. Dr. Cardell would love to hear from you.

Questions, Comments, Criticisms, or Witty Remarks:

* Required information
1000
Enter the third word of this sentence.
Drag & drop images (max 3)
Powered by Commentics

Responses

Avatar
New
Annheeete Oakleysays...

Your framing of the welfare state as a form of codependency is a compelling way to translate an economic dynamic into something more psychologically legible.

What stands out is the claim that these systems persist not because they solve problems, but because they satisfy the incentives of those maintaining them—particularly the alignment between political power and perceived moral virtue.

I’m interested in how you evaluate that claim through an evidentiary lens. Specifically, what threshold of observable outcomes would be sufficient to distinguish between a system that is structurally dependent versus one that is simply inefficient or mismanaged?

Looking forward to exploring this further in our conversation.

Recent Articles

Newest to Oldest

The DSA Delusion #5

The DSA Delusion #4

The DSA Delusion #3

The DSA Delusion #2

The DSA Delusion #1

A Humble Guardian

Eco-Economic Errors

Economic Ecosystems

Nature Ain't Simple

Nature's Lessons

Ecology and Economy

Grievance Culture

The Economics of Envy

The Myth Makers

Ambiguity Aversion

Inequality Is Not Unjust

Capitalist Conundrum

Utopia? Reprise

Jevons' Paradox

Sneak Preview #9

Morality of Capitalism

Sneak Preview #8

Capitalism Explained

Sneak Preview #7

A Venezuela Vision

Sneak Preview #6

Collectivism?

Sneak Preview #5

A Landscape Paradox

Sneak Preview #4

NarcisSocialism #3

Sneak Preview #3

Mamdani Madness

Sneak Preview #2

Imagine No Capitalism

NarcisSocialism #2

Sneak Preview #1

Creeping Socialism?

NarcisSocialism #1

Maximize Your Value

Triple Your Income?

How to Create Value

Values Create Value

Do You Create Value?

Amazon Delivers

The Laffer Curve

Social Security Fix

A Story about Spending

The New Natural Law

Economic Outlook 2025

Can Feet Vote?

BIG Numbers

The Wrong Ruler

Butterfly Economics

Are You an Economy?

Worldwide Wealth

Undoing Inflation

Electionomics

Education Emergency

Election Economics

Meritocracy Matters

How Is It Possible?

Building Wealth

July 4th Worldwide

American Capitalism

And the winner is…

Utopia?

Stagflation

Sense of Purpose

Inflation & Stocks

The Dangers of Debt

Fixing Capitalism

Shrinkflation?

Employment Truth

Achievement Economy

Anti-Social Policy?

Does Amazon Deliver

The Socialist Religion

Defeating Poverty

Economic Myths #3

Economic Myths #2

Economic Myths #1

Who's a Capitalist?

More Pie Please

The Bubble Tax

Colonial-Socialism?

Income Inequality

Is Greed Good?

Racism & Economics

Death by Diet

Crony Capitalism?

No More Do-overs!

Model Behavior

Climate Change Cure

Then & Now Part 3

Then & Now Part 2

Then & Now Part 1

Democratic Socialism?

Capitalism Attacked

Debt Limit

Economic Error

Tax Hikes

Spontaneous Order?

Value and Worth

Evidentiary Econ

Taxing Corporations

Gov't Codependency

Causes of Inflation

What Is Capitalism

What Is It Worth?

CRT Explained

What Is Economics?

Economic Systems

Work Adding Value